‘Disposing the unwanted’: the resurgence of deportations to third countries

We zijn getuige van de heropleving in de Europese Unie van een politiek beleid dat erop gericht is ‘ongewenste migranten’ naar derde landen te deporteren. De gebruikte terminologie rond ‘deportaties’ is tegenwoordig misschien wat technisch van aard om de harde realiteit proberen te verbloemen: externalisering, terugkeercentra, doorreisknooppunten, overname, migratiepartnerschappen…

Maar de onderliggende logica is overal heel duidelijk: het ‘kwijtraken van de ongewensten’. Het wegsturen van degenen van wie wordt aangenomen dat ze ‘ergens anders’ thuishoren. Hen te behandelen zoals wat Zygmunt Bauman noemde ‘verspilde levens’. Mensen die door de heersende sociale en politieke orde overbodig zijn geworden.

In een wetenschappelijk artikel dat onlangs verscheen in ‘Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space’ schrijven Henk van Houtum, hoogleraar aan de Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen en zijn collega John Nightingale over ’Disposing the unwanted: The UK-Rwanda deal and the resurgence of deportations to third countries’.

In this article, we argue that, although the UK–Rwanda deal was cancelled, it helped to normalise this dehumanising, neo-colonial practice.

What was presented as an exceptional and controversial British experiment has increasingly become part of a broader policy repertoire: moving people who are deemed unwanted not simply out of a country, but out of sight—and beyond the territorial reach of the state that seeks to expel them.

In doing so, it is mainstreaming the political strategy of ‘purifying’ societies that far-right movements, like the AfD in Germany, have long advocated.

Italy’s arrangement with Albania

Italy’s arrangement with Albania is a highly visible European example. That model is now being normalized further and copied.

Via the EU Migration Pact the EU has agreed on new return rules that would allow member states to establish ‘return hubs’ in third countries.

Also the Netherlands has already made arrangements with Uganda for a ‘transit hub’ and, in its new coalition agreement, explicitly supports return and transit hubs and greater scope for agreements with countries outside Europe.

Other European states are exploring similar arrangements, while the United States is also expanding third-country deportations.

Normalising xenophobia

Externalising borders provokes and normalises xenophobia and, crucially, externalises and deepens inequalities in the right to move. It deepens the passport apartheid—the hierarchy of mobility rights—and reinforces a world in which people are increasingly treated as having unequal claims to movement, protection, and belonging (see our article on the inequality trap of visa borders https://lnkd.in/gPEDV8b).

Depending on their descent, some human beings in this world move across borders with passports that open doors, their mobility treated as both an asset and a right.

Others encounter borders as violent interventions: detention and removal to places with which they have no meaningful connection at all.

The danger is therefore not only that borders are being externalised. It is that human beings themselves are being externalized — removed from view, stripped of belonging, and treated as disposable.

The real danger of outsourcing migration control is that it is leading to the outsourcing of humanity.

Henk van Houtum

Henk van Houtum is hoogleraar politieke geografie aan de Radboud Universiteit in Nijmegen (NL). Hij is er hoofd van de afdeling Political Geography & Geopolitics. Zijn bekendste boek is: ‘Free the Map. From Atlas to Hermes: a new cartography of borders and migration’ (nai010.com)

Henk van Houtum en John Nightingale, Disposing the unwanted: The UK-Rwanda deal and the resurgence of deportations to third countries, in‘Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space‘, 2026, het integrale wetenschappelijke artikel kan gratis worden gedownload op https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/23996544261475684

Bron: https://lnkd.in/ex47njR3

Lees ook:


Lees ook (inhoud oktober 2026)